Entry: When I am 74 Saturday, July 22, 2006



Elderly man arrested for hitting MP

AN elderly man was arrested for punching Member of Parliament Seng Han Thong on Thursday evening and leaving him with a bruised lip.

 

The punch came during Mr Seng's meet-the-people session, when the Chinese man — a former taxi driver — came to seek the Yio Chu Kang MP's help to reinstate his terminated taxi contract.

 

When it was his turn to see the MP, he reportedly raised his voice at Mr Seng and stunned those present by hitting him.

 

In a statement, the police said it received a call for assistance at about 9.35pm on Thursday. And when its officers arrived, the staff at Ang Mo Kio's Community & Education Centre — where the session was conducted — had already detained the man, who is in his 70s.

 

Mr Seng had "suffered a bruised lip and had declined medical attention", the police added. The man, who was arrested for assaulting a public servant, cannot be named as the case is under investigation.

 

Today understands that the 74-year-old man, who is currently out on bail, was formerly a taxi driver with ComfortDelGro and was unhappy with the company for terminating his contract.

 

When contacted, ComfortDelGro spokesperson Tammy Tan confirmed that the man's contract was terminated in February 2002 for "rude behaviour and for a threat made against a customer".

 

Said Ms Tan: "As (he) is no longer a hirer with the company, we are not able to go into details about the case. We however stand by our decision to terminate him based on the threats he made to the customer in a letter he wrote."

 

On the assault, Ms Tan added: "The police is currently investigating the matter and we are rendering them all assistance."

 

Mr Seng is currently in Shanghai on business. When contacted, the divisonal director for the National Trades Union Congress' administration and research unit told Today that he was "all right" but declined to comment further. Nonetheless, he said that he was not unduly shaken by the assault.

 

"I continued meeting the residents until around 11pm and then went to board my flight at midnight," he added.

 

— Loh Chee Kong

 

Mr Seng was a journalist with Zaobao before entering politics. He is probably best-known for his role as the editor of MM Lee's memoirs. According to the NTUC, he is also an advisor to the taxi operator associations.

This incident interested me for two reasons.

Firstly, this is probably the first time anyone had ever punched an MP in Singapore.
Secondly, and more importantly, was that a man as old as 74 years old, having been unemployed for the last 4 years, was still desperately looking for help to secure employment.

I would be interested to understand his financial situation.

Is he single?
Or had he been neglected by his children?

Are his children still dependent on him?
Or are his children already financially independent but are themselves also struggling?

Had he been living beyond his means?
Had he exhausted all his savings in the 4 years of unemployment?

Is he mentally unstable?
Or driven to rage by his circumstances?

Does he have any other siblings or relatives?
Who else can he turn to for help?

Does he qualify as a 'needy'?
Where is our safety net for people like him?

Until more facts emerge, it would be difficult to comment on his actions.
But, given that this is probably the first time anyone dared to punch an MP, is this a sign of times?

Something must have cracked inside a person to cause him to punch someone whom he is asking for help. I have many questions but no satisfactory answers.

Is there a group of low-income badly hit by cost of living pressures and unemployment?
How do they perceive the help that had been given so far?

Had their MPs been helpful?
Are they seen as giving voice to their concerns or had they been perceived as being the government's voice instead?

The prevailing assumption is that the support base of the PAP is those born before 1970.
Is this an indication that the older generation is also unhappy with the PAP?

For me, this incident is a wake-up call.

Will I be financially independent at 74?
Can I afford medical expenses?

I value my financial independence very much.
Many Ministers had suggested that one should rely on your family as the social safety net.

In an increasingly volatile environment, I think it is unrealistic to expect your children to be able to support their families and you. I had come across several taxi-drivers who resumed driving taxis after a break of 5-10 years when their children went out of work.

Well, as the Ministers urged, we should all continue to work for as long as we can.
Yeah, right.
Not many organisations are prepared to employ people well into their 80s.

Technorati:

   9 comments

anonymous
July 22, 2006   08:25 PM PDT
 
while i agree with the general direction of your analysis, i thought that maybe you should have been clearer in your condemnation of the 74-year old man's actions? it would have lent a bit more credibility to the analysis that would follow.
waterchild
July 23, 2006   09:15 AM PDT
 
Hi, anonymous,

My first reaction on reading this was sympathy for a 74-year-old who was still desparately looking for a job.

As the facts of the case were still not clear, I had reserved comment on both parties. Instead, I had attempted a break-down of some of the possible reasons why he had to resort to violence to make his point - the 74-year-old's personal circumstances and the potential perceptions that others may have of the MP.

JK
July 23, 2006   05:53 PM PDT
 
Lots of comments here

http://forums.delphiforums.com/sammyboymod/messages?msg=111952.1

http://forums.delphiforums.com/sammyboymod/messages?msg=111977.1
Mark
July 23, 2006   05:55 PM PDT
 
Violence is not the way. The Old Man should get lawyers to sue PAP MP Seng Han Thong instead....LOL.....it is the Singapore Way.

We should get the experts in FIFA to investigate since their experience is still fresh with the Zinedane Zidane & Marco Materazzi case. Singapore should learn from those experts in FIFA

Maybe FIFA will fine both and ban Old Man from driving Taxi for some years and ban Seng Han Thong for one or two elections....LOL....

Anyway, PAP MP Seng Han Thong must have said something nasty that provoked the rash action but what did he say? Singaporeans might never know given our climate of Controlled Information.

The mainstream media had been busy painting a good picture of Seng Han Thong as the victim and the Old Man as The Evil One. It is the "North Korean Time " again.


I always give discount to local media when they report such scenarios and local political news. I do this because of their long and bad history of being biased towards PAP. Remember, former minister Tony Tan is Chairman of SPH. Must give discount.


I never agree on former political members sitting on company boards because of "Conflict of Interest" issues especially on media companies.


Another point, what happen to Singapore's Social Security System? Has it collapsed? I mean this Old Man is already 74 years old and yet still get so agitated over job issues and cannot retire. Is this the standard of living in Singapore? Must we really work until our dying day?


This is a very big problem and if left uncheck, my generation will perish when it is our turn to become senior citizens.

One more point, how come Seng Han Thong got time to go Shanghai for trips? Given the fact MPs have a huge load of information to digest for Town Council work and Parliament work, he still got time for business trips?

The wonder some laws and practices are still outdated today. What if Parliament has started, will he turn up for Parliament,sleep in Parliament or just go there to mark attendance? I do not think he can multi task and do his MP job properly and give 100% commitment which we elected him for.

I mean even PM Lee Hsien Loong admitted he cannot handle 10-20 Opposition MPs and multi task, I expect less from a normal PAP MP...LOL
waterchild
July 24, 2006   01:46 PM PDT
 
Hi, Mark,

I agree with your sentiments about having to work till our last days.
Some mainland Chinese who migrated to Singapore told me they felt that Singaporeans have a hard life as there is no social safety net.

What is more worrying is that even if one is prepared to accept life and work till one's last days, is there anyone prepared to employ you?

In the past, people used to say : "At most go and drive a taxi." Now, going by the experiences of this 74-year-old man, driving taxi is out too.
eve
July 25, 2006   12:51 AM PDT
 
errr, as an aside,
i read in zaobao that the uncle said he's not trying to secure his employment at this age. he just wanted to pursue 'justice' - though he was not at fault but comfort taxi terminated his contract... his family was upset with him and thought he was at fault when he got fired. so he said he wanted to seek justice pertaining to this matter.
Mrs Goh
July 25, 2006   10:54 AM PDT
 
The poor man had to work. He lost his son to cancer and is left with his daughter-in-law with a baby.

Actually, some of us with aged folks at home will know that old folks can be quite naggy and "rude".

These people did not have the benefit of education like we do.

Younger singaporeans should be more tolerant towards them.

The whole episode just indicate that our society has cracks running through which will become deeper and collapse one day.
Name
July 25, 2006   11:52 AM PDT
 
In the words of that perm sec Bilala Kausikan "let's wait for them to die off'. LOL
gecko
July 31, 2006   04:24 PM PDT
 
unfortunately, most singaporeans who still rely on mainstream media would not ponder to the extent you did, thanks to their superficial reportage.

Leave a Comment:

Name


Homepage (optional)


Comments